17 November 2013

Random Tech Musings

     As this is my final post for the fall, I thought I would write about some things I have thought about during this semester related to technology and education. I don't know if any of these ideas relate to each other, but I still wanted to get them out there.
     First, I have been thinking about how sometimes outdated technology is more effective than newer technology. In my placement this fall, we have used VHS tapes and laser discs to show videos, and one thing I have noticed about using these types of media have a bit of a nostalgic feel to them. in EDUC 511, we have talked about how students need to learn the discourse of science, and in some sense, I think using older types of media contribute to this. When we pull out a VHS tape, it seems like students sense that they are being brought into the discipline. This isn't some YouTube video anyone can watch, this is a VHS tape that has been around for decades, and there is some history to it. I'm not sure if I'm explaining this the way I want, but this is always what I have felt.
     Second, another thing I have noticed in some other posts by interns and in discussions we have had in classes is that newer technology can be so clunky sometimes. I think this kind of goes back to what we talked about over the summer about using technology just for the sake of using it. If technology is to be used, it should be used in a manner that fits; it can't be forced into a situation that is not conducive to using it. A comment by Claire to one of my other posts shows an example of this. The students at her school have ipads they use for the four years they are at the school. She said that they can be useful for reading things, but for writing, they seem to be a bit clunky. For something like reading, using ipads can be quite useful, but in other situations, like writing, it seems like the ipads are used just because the students have them.
     Finally, I wanted to mention something about the webinars that we did. While I really enjoyed using technology to do this project, I think that using webinars in a classroom would not be a good idea. I found it very difficult to focus on the webinars I participated in, and I don't feel like I got as much out of them as I would have if I was sitting in a classroom watching a presentation. I think that some of the things we did in the webinars was cool, like sharing screens and participating in polls, but with using these tools, I think the focus was on the technique we used rather than what we were actually sharing while using the technique. For instance, my group talked about Duolingo, a tool you can use to learn another language. We used the screen sharing tool to show what the interface of Duolingo looks like, but if you look at the chat box when we started sharing the screen, most of the comments were on how cool this technique was.
     So, this is the final post of the fall, and until next time, have a good rest of the year, and I will continue blogging at some point in the future.

2 comments:

  1. Hey Mike!

    I think your comments about the VHS tapes are really interesting. We have a few science tools in our classroom that are outdated and "ancient" and the physics and math students love looking at those more than anything else in the classroom. Maybe you're right - they feel like it's actually pulling them into the discipline. I also think, at least in our classroom, that it has something to do with their views about that object being connected to the teacher. If Mr. Tuttle used this when he was a kid, and he's so smart and a teacher now, then if WE use it, we'll be smart too. I could be off on my thinking there, but I've felt that has something to do with it.

    I also agree with you that I would not use Webinars in my classroom. Like you said, it would be very easy for students to be logged in to a webinar but be unfocused and working on other tasks during it. I liked learning how to use the tool, but I don't feel as though I really learned the material people presented as much as I just learned how to navigate through blackboard collaborate. Maybe this was the point of the assignment though? I'm not sure.

    Thanks for your post!
    Morgan

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mike, I was also intrigued by your observations about older technology, and I think it could be very cool to further explore this idea in your teaching. I don't know if your observations here are linked to a personal interest in vintage technology, but if that's the case, all the better...you might enjoy this" , for example, and be able to figure out ingenious ways of weaving such things into your teaching.

    ReplyDelete